Which Football Game Should I get?

Posted by Paul on December 11, 2011 | Short Link

As far as baseball games go, Strat-o-Matic vs. APBA is an age old debate that isn’t going to end any time soon.  You might have better luck converting a Lutheran to a Protestant than a Strat-player to an APBA-baller when it comes to the respective baseball games.

Hal Richman, founder of Strat-o-Matic, compared tabletop gamers to political parties in a 2009 interview with USA Today: “Generally, you don’t switch parties,” says Richman. “Once a Democrat, always a Democrat. Once a Republican, always a Republican. It’s your choice.”

In baseball, I play Strat-o-Matic.  I love it.  I’ve never tried the APBA game, I’ve never tried Statis Pro, or Replay, or Gen1400′s DICE baseball, or 15 Minute Baseball, or Cardboard Baseball, or Extra Bases, or Out of the Park, or Diamond Mind, or Pursue the Pennant, or any of the other million bazillion baseball games.  I play Strat-o-Matic.  One day I might give APBA a whirl, most likely with one of their deadball sets that Strat doesn’t seem to have any interest in releasing, but in the meantime, I have more Strat cards than I can possibly get to for years to come.

The first Strat Football card image I found online...Dave Krieg?

But as for football games, I am unaffiliated.  I’ve never played ANY football games.  I had a football game as a kid that I made up myself that was really fun, but I lost the rules and charts years and years ago.  One day I may try to recreate it.  In the meantime, which football game should I get?

Here is what I’m looking for (card & dice only, please):

  1. easy solitaire play – I only plan to play solitaire, so I’d need a game with play calling that isn’t dependent on surprising or out-coaching your opponent
  2. realistic stats – I like stats, and I’d like complete game stats for offensive skill players, and hopefully defensive tackles, sacks and interceptions
  3. game play in 45 min – 1 hr max (1/2 hour would be even better)
  4. individual player cards for skill players at least – I prefer player cards over team roster cards or sheets, but this is not a deal breaker
  5. not too much decision making – I love football, but I’m no football coach.  Especially with defensive formations, I can get lost in the complexity of all the player movement and who covers whom
  6. preferably have college football teams available – I’d love to replay a couple USC seasons, but this isn’t a deal killer either
I think that’s it.  Right now I’m leaning toward APBA Football or the newly-released Fast Action Football from Downey Games.  I’ve heard great things about both of these games.

17 Comments

  • Bobby5960 says:

    Going to chime in here. Have a played only a few football games out there. For me, SOM has been the best for face to face game. Can be played solitaire but shines as FtF. Good stats but can’t remember what playing time was but thinking it was over 2 hours. Solitaire wise, I have played a lot of SI Football/Paydirt/Red Zone. Can quickly take it out of the box and start playing. Play time is around 90 minutes and has a college FB version. Problem with it is no individual players. The football game I am messing with right now is Second Season from PLAAY.com. Not sure how the stats are going to be, does have individual players but on a overall team sheet, all plays are resolved based on matchups which is nice and results are discreptive. No college teams that I am aware of (rules for rating players are included tho). Only down side for me is this play time. It seems to takes me well over 2 hours to play a game because of chart flipping and not enough games played to get the system down. I think it is worth a look.
    Bob

  • Bobby5960 says:

    Oh, I have a copy of APBA Football but have not played it yet. To busy playing the soccer game……………..

  • Paul says:

    Thanks for the suggestions, Bob. I’ve heard good things about Second Season, too. I think I’m still leaning toward APBA or Fast Action Football, though. But, like you, I have plenty of other games (APBA Soccer especially) to play in the meantime.

  • Russ says:

    Not sure if you found a game, but Inside Blitz from Inside Sports games has a really nice football game with a great solitaire system. In fact all their offerings are good.

  • Russ says:

    Well your in for a treat then…. The football game has a wonderfull solitaire system for play calling. It’s a full fledged game though that usually clocks in at around 1.5 hours. Their baseball game is very unique it has an engine based on DIPS where it all starts on the pitchers card….

    http://www.insidesportsgames.org/games.htm

    • Paul says:

      You guys are really opening up a new world for me with all these football games. Russ, I’ve been looking at Inside Blitz and that game may be the most impressive yet. The only thing I don’t like about what I see is the lack of available college seasons. If they come out with the 2011 college season before I make a purchase, this may end up being the game I get. I still might get it anyway.

  • Tim says:

    You might take a look at “Second Season”. I’m not sure how long it plays but it’s got some good reviews. See: http://www.plaay.com/

  • kyle says:

    how would actionpc ever be called bettter than strat yep young 13 tr olds play still play strat

  • John says:

    I recommend the current version of Paydirt, one called “Data Driven Football” and the other called “Mays Football.” Contrary to what’s been said, in my opinion the absence of individual player cards is a plus, not a minus. The game plays quicker without them. Nine offensive plays (Line Plunge, Off Tackle, End Run, Draw Play, Screen Pass, Short Pass, Medium Pass, Long Pass, Sideline Pass) and Six defensive formations (Standard, Short Yardage, Spread, Pass Prevent Short, Pass Prevent Long, Blitz).

    There is a solitaire system which permits you to play both offenses, with the defenses picked for you, or you can play offense and defense for one team and the system will play the opponent. There is both a board version and a computer version. Additionally, in Mays Football, you can pick up some old time teams.

    http://www.datadrivenfootball.com
    http://www.maysfootball.com

  • james kurylas says:

    Hello,
    First let me say that I’m 66 years old and just retired. Obviously,I have some extra time on my hands.I’ve played Bowl Bound and Paydirt many times.However,I played the board game versions and really liked the games.I would like to play both again but I’m computer illiterate. Would I be able to learn to play these games on my computer. Are these games hard to master.Also I would be playing these games in solitaire fashion. I even have my own solitaire method to play these on the board game. To be honest if I could find the board game with sheets from the 90′s and 2000′s I’d prefer that but it doesn’t seem anyone prints those.Thank you for your time and consideration.
    Jim

    • Paul says:

      Hi Jim, I don’t know much about those two games, but if I were you I’d click on the two links in the comment above yours. Another source you might try is the Table Top Sports Forum at Delphi. Here is the link to the forum: http://forums.delphiforums.com/tabletopsports/

      There are a lot of helpful guys over there (many around your age, too!). I’d ask them for their opinion on Paydirt’s computer versions and what might be right for you.

      Good luck!
      Paul

  • Jerry Hoppe says:

    Hi: I’ve played board games for years, mostly baseball on APBA. I would like to play football on board games too. I play solitaire and I like working with individual player cards. I’ve been looking at strat-o-matic, but I’m not sure if I can play that solitaire or not. I’m not too interested in playing on computer. Or is there another game out there that would be better. Thanks, Jerry.

    • Paul says:

      Hi Jerry,
      There are a ton of great football games, as you can tell by some of the responses to this article. I have been playing Strat Football (basic) solitaire and I find it to be a great game. Lately, my favorite game for solitaire football has been Diggin’ Deep Football. I also enjoy Second Season a lot, too.

      Good luck finding the one that’s right for you, I hope you enjoy the process while you’re looking for it.

      Paul

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Copyright © 2011-2014 One for Five All rights reserved.
This site is using the Shades theme, v2.1.1, from BuyNowShop.com.